In partnership with
Confidence | Illusion of Explanatory Depth
THE THOUGHT
Wonder shrinks as confidence grows.
My coworker's daughter has mastered the art of questions.
Alice wonders what makes a beet purple. She ponders how airplanes can soar. She has wild theories about why her mom's hair is curly, and deep curiosities about the place the sun goes.
Her parents scramble to explain pigments and physics, but each explanation breeds three additional paths. Eventually there is only one answer: "it just works." She shrugs and moves on.
I remember a time when questions were vital, when no explanation was ever enough. Like Alice, I once dreamt of questions. Do you remember when not knowing felt rough?
One day we learn all the shortcuts, and superficial understanding becomes the new norm. No door is allowed to stay open. Complexity flattens into something we "know."
Have you learned to love "it just works"?
The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.
THE DIVE
The Comfort of Surface Knowledge
The transformation from endless questions to comfortable answers reveals something profound about human psychology. Coined by psychologists Leonid Rozenblit and Frank Keil, the Illusion of Explanatory Depth reveals how we systematically overestimate our understanding of everyday phenomena.
When we encounter complex systems, our minds create shortcuts, filling gaps with assumptions that feel satisfying but lack substance. We construct what feels like a complete picture from fragments, never realizing how much we have fabricated. We confuse familiarity with comprehension.
Consider something as mundane as a toilet. We confidently understand flushing: "Water goes down, waste disappears." This explanation feels complete until someone asks: what creates the suction? How does the tank refill? Suddenly, most of us face complete ignorance of a system we use daily.
How does soap actually clean things? How do painkillers know where the pain is? How do magnets work?
Our need for coherence often trumps accuracy. Our brain generates plausible-sounding connections, creating an illusion of depth where only surface knowledge exists. Rather than admit uncertainty, we prefer confident but shallow explanations.
The Illusion of Explanatory Depth: Unveiling Hidden Ignorance.
This overestimation serves a deeper psychological purpose. We need to feel competent in a complex world. Admitting ignorance threatens our sense of agency and control, so we double down rather than acknowledge our limits.
Worse, this illusion shapes our decision-making confidence. We vote, invest, and make life choices based on explanations we cannot actually defend, convinced of our reasoning while operating on little more than sophisticated guesswork.
Is it possible to unlearn our confident ignorance?
THE PRACTICE
Rediscovering Curiosity
Children ask relentless questions because they naturally exist in a state of intellectual humility. Around ages 6-8, a shift happens: we develop pattern recognition, social pressure increases, and we learn to use things without understanding how they work. Practice being a child.
Test yourself: The Decision Lab breaks down this exact psychological phenomenon with a brilliant thought experiment. Try explaining how a toilet works to this alien and watch your confidence crumble.
Practice intellectual humility. When someone asks you to explain something and you realize you cannot, try responding with: "I know that it works, but I do not actually understand how." The distinction between operational knowledge and explanatory knowledge can transform how you approach learning and decision-making.
The goal is developing an honest relationship with the limits of our knowledge. Distinguish between what we actually understand and what we simply recognize.
NOTEWORTHY
Discover: The Knowledge Illusion by Steven Sloman and Philip Fernbach — A book that will shatter your confidence in your own brain (in the best possible way).
Watch: The Illusion of Understanding by Phil Fernbach — A 15-minute talk that explains the psychology behind every heated argument you've ever witnessed.
Explore: Velocipedia by Gianluca Gimini — A collection where people tried to draw bicycles from memory. The results are both hilarious and deeply unsettling.
COMMUNITY
SUPPORT THE THOUGHT
If this exploration added something meaningful to your week, consider supporting the research and writing that makes it possible. Support the work here.
This edition contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting our newsletter!